The Porous University Symposium: Inquiry as openness; Re-imagining the university, its commitments and responsibilities by Emanuele Bardone and Maarja Taaler
While it is usually connected to widening participation, openness can also be interpreted as the very core element constituting inquiry as a mode of engagement in and with the world. Our provocation focuses on inquiry as openness in university.
Our starting point is an experience matured in schools as ethnographers in a European project called “Ark of Inquiry” focusing on inquiry learning. In this project we had a chance to observe how inquiries were conducted in several Estonian schools. Interestingly, the single cases observed varied along a continuum that went from a highly scripted format to a more open one.
On the one extreme, students were reduced to mere executors of a recipe-type of activity. The teacher stepped out of the process making sure that all the steps were properly followed. On the other, students were given the chance to make several key decisions during the inquiry, forcing the teacher to step into the process, tinkering with students’ suggestions and improvise.
Although inquiries practised in school are not (fully) comparable with those conducted by researchers and students in their apprenticeship, this experience made us think. As we have observed, inquiry loses its reason d’etre when it is pursued instrumentally.
If in schools this means relying on a recipe-type of format, in university it means limiting the possibility of re-defining problems, improvising on the basis of chance encounters, experimenting with new methods of collecting as well as presenting “data”.
If we do not limit such possibilities, what kind of institutions can we imagine? How could we re-frame commitments and responsibilities? How would we re-imagine the engagement of actors outside the university?
Would inquiry as openness lead to chaos and dismissal of the university? Does it describe an ideal that would never fit any institutional framework? How would it be financially supported and sustainable?
About the Presenter
Emanuele Bardone is a Senior Researcher at the Centre for Educational Technology, Institute of Education, of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has published extensively and written the book Seeking Chances: From Biased Rationality to Distributed Cognition. He held a Marie Curie Fellowship between the years 2011 and 2014 at the Institute of Informatics, Tallinn University, Estonia, where he taught Philosophy of Human-Computer Interaction and Philosophy of Cognition in the International Master program on Human-Computer Interaction. He was awarded his PhD in Philosophy from the University of Pavia, Italy, where he taught Cognitive Philosophy from 2009 to 2011.
- The appeal of gossiping fallacies and its eco-logical roots By Lorenzo Magnani and Emanuele Bardone
- Sharing Representations and Creating Chances through Cognitive Niche Construction. The Role of Affordances and Abduction By Lorenzo Magnani and Emanuele Bardone
- Docility and through doing morality: An alternative approach to ethics By Davide Secchi and Emanuele Bardone
- Socially distributed cognition and intra-organizational bandwagon: Theoretical framework, model, and simulation By Davide Secchi and Emanuele Bardone
- A Model of Organizational Bandwagon By Davide Secchi and Emanuele Bardone
- Distributed cognition: A research agenda for management By Davide Secchi and Emanuele Bardone
- Emanuele Bardone: Seeking chances: from biased rationality to distributed cognition
- Seeking chances: from biased rationality to distributed cognition (hardback)(series: cognitive systems monographs)
- The Internet as a Moral Mediator. The Quest for Democracy
- La moralidad de las tecnologías cotidianas
- From Epistemic Luck to Chance-Seeking
- Turning Down a Chance An Argument from Simplicity
- The Notion of Docility: The Social Dimension of Distributing Cognition
- Building Cognitive Niches: The Role of Affordances
- Fallacies and Cognition: The Rationale of Being Fallacious
- The Virtues and Vices of Biased Rationality: An Eco-Cognitive Account
- Removing bounds to rationality. The cognitive role of external resources
- Affordances as Abductive Anchors
- Constructing Cognitive Niches
- Seeking chances through interface design the role of abduction
- THE PROMISE OF E-DEMOCRACY
- The Social Face of Bandwagon: Model and Simulation
- Ambient Intelligence as Cognitive Niche Enrichment
- Extending the Bounded Rationality Model: The Distributed Cognition Approach
- Moving the Bonds: Distributing Cognition through Cognitive Niche Construction
- Abduction and Web Interface Design
- Bounded Rationality as Biased Rationality: Virtues, Vices, and Assumptions
- Silent Knowns, Bricolage, and Chance-Seeking
- Not by Luck Alone: The Importance of Chance-Seeking and Silent Knowledge in Abductive Cognition
- Perverting Activism: Cyberactivism and Its Potential Failures In Enhancing Democratic Institutions
- Encyclopedia of human computer interaction
- Moral Mediators in HCI
- Docility and ‘through doing’ morality: An alternative approach to ethics
- Distributed Morality: Externalizing Ethical Knowledge in Technological Artifacts
- Faking Chance
- Chances, affordances, and cognitive niche construction: the plasticity of environmental situatedness
- Unintended Affordances as Violent Mediators: Maladaptive Effects of Technologically Enriched Human Niches
- Oltre le culture: valori e contesti della comunicazione interculturale
- Sharing representations through cognitive niche construction
- Distributed cognition: A research agenda for management
- The appeal of gossiping fallacies and its eco-logical roots
- Designing human interfaces. The role of abduction
- Seeking chances: from biased rationality to distributed cognition
- Super-docility in organizations: An evolutionary model
- Sharing representations and creating chances through cognitive niche construction. The role of affordances and abduction
- Oltre le culture: valori e contesti della comunicazione interculturale | Ibis By Enzo Rossi and Emanuele Bardone